Have you ever cringed or got offended when your friend or someone called anime ‘Cartoon’ (Anime VS Cartoon Beef). Feel assured you are not the only one who feels that way. To your surprise most of the anime fans get offended when someone calls anime -cartoon.
I tried to look into this beef and tried to learn the reason why I, and many other anime fans react this way even though I didn’t have any reason it was just a natural reaction. So, I went online looking for a few reason and then form few of my opinion.
So, in this blog I would like to share those reasons with you guys.
Anime VS Cartoon Beef
Cultural and Artistic Differences:
First let’s finish of with the basic which most of us are familiar with.
Origin And Art Style-
As most of us are already aware, anime originates from Japan, whereas cartoons originate in Western countries, and both of them have different approaches to their targeted audiences.
Anime is highly influenced by Japanese culture, and they show every bit of it in anime, creating an amazing backdrop. In contrast, cartoons are lighter without any significant cultural elements, so audiences do not connect as deeply with them and do not feel the urge to defend them in any way.
Most anime viewers grew up watching cartoons, but as we matured, many of us shifted to anime. This transition reflects our growth over time. It doesn’t mean we disrespect cartoons; we just prefer not to compare them to anime.
As I’ve already explained, we don’t feel as attached to cartoons as we do to anime. The cultural origins and unique art style of anime create a deeper connection, making all the difference.
Target Audience-
One aspect that plays an important role in the anime vs. cartoon debate is the target audience. Though I have touched on this in a previous section, let’s delve deeper into that part.
Anime often focuses on adults, with deep storylines, sophisticated animation, and well-developed characters, aiming to convey meaningful messages to the audience. In contrast, cartoons typically target children, who may not consider story and other aspects as deeply. These shows are often more humorous and involve silly antics that appeal to kids.
Thus, the difference in target age and cultural origin creates a significant divide in this debate. Interestingly, many children are unaware that this debate even exists and continue to enjoy their beloved cartoons without concern.
Complex Themes-
Anime as a whole covers almost every genre. From light, action, and adventure to dark, complex, and mature topics, anime encompasses everything. This diversity is not present in Western cartoons, leading to the perception that anime is more serious and sophisticated. As a result, anime viewers cringe at the comparison between the two.
Cultural Misunderstanding–
But you know all these point are the core of this Blog, in my opinion the core of this beef is Stereotyping and Recognition. Let me explain the two a little bit.
Stereotyping-
I think why anime lovers are offended by refereeing anime as cartoon is because of stereotyping and labeling anime as cartoons can feel reductive and dismissive, reinforcing stereotypes that anime is childish or simplistic.
Recognition-
This point is yet another important aspect that every anime viewers stands with. Anime fans wants anime to be recognized for its unique qualities and contributions to the art of animation. And by comparing they fell anime being disrespect as cartoon does not offer any value addition as anime does.
Now, the final point that I think contributes to this Anime VS Cartoon beef is Fandom Identity.
Fandom Identity–
What I mean from this is that the anime community most of the time takes pride in its distinct identity and cultural heritage that anime bring with it. Whereas the “cartoon” label can undermine this sense of community and the unique cultural aspects of anime.
And this pride is connected with the respect for the medium and its creator and the “cartoon” label can feel like a lack of appreciation for the depth and artistry involved in anime production.
I think I have cleared a little bit of your doubt as to why there is this Anime VS Cartoon beef going all the time. And if you still have any query feel free to comment I would be more than happy to answer your question.
Before, I take my leave I would like to suggest my latest Blog to you which I you will love to read-
10 Anime With Best Storyline ( Not So Popular) | AY
